At the start of the episode, Casey is offered a position on the Panhellenic board and her first task is to find out the conditions surrounding the Gamma Psi fire. She, however, decides to come clean to the president of the Gamma Psi house who tries to blackmail her into giving Gamma Psi the ZBZ house until the Gamma Psi house is built. Evan advises her to find the truth behind Songfest as a way of getting even with Gamma Psi or at least escaping expulsion, ridicule and the loss of the ZBZ house.
Last season on Greek we left our beloved Zeta Beta Zeta girls wondering if they were the cause of the fire that burned down the Gamma Psi sorority house. Cappie parted ways with Evan after a trick that led to the expulsion of some Kappa Tau brothers. As for hook ups, Cappie got back with Casey, Dale and Rusty were neutral, Grant decided to tell his parents about his sexual orientation and Evan may have started something off with Rebecca.
Now that Betty has moved into her own apartment and Matt is gone she feels lonely. Therefore, this week she feels that she needs to connect with her neighbors and thus she throws a karaoke party. However, before the party has even begun, burglars are unwittingly let in who steal numerous things.
In the opening of the third episode of The Secret Life of The American Teenager, Ricky is seen cleaning up the broken glass on the floor of the butcher shop. Ricky soon finds out that Adrian threw her phone towards the window of the butcher shop because she found out about him cheating on her. Since the cops are not going to press charges, Ricky and Adrian have to find out how to pay for repairs. Furthermore, Amy has anxiety about going back to school because she anticipates that Ben will soon break up with her.
In the second episode of The Secret Life of the American Teenager viewers have a chance to finally meet Ben’s Bologna Fling, Maria. Maria and Ben are caught sneaking around in Ben’s bedroom when his father comes in and wonders what’s going on. Afterwards, Amy and Anne are still out of town, and is grocery shopping when Anne runs into her old high school boyfriend who has a son that flirts with Amy. Amy is immediately attracted to this random guy named Jimmy and exchanges phone numbers with him.